Moral issues of embryonic stem cell research

Researchers and SCROs need to distinguish core ethical standards that are accepted by international consensus—informed consent and an acceptable balance of benefits and risks—from standards that vary across jurisdictions and cultures.

But even if one holds that this is a morally significant distinction, it is not clear that it is felicitous to characterize the destruction of spare embryos as an unintended but foreseeable side-effect of creating embryos for fertility treatment. We very often think of the value of lives from the inside, as it were, in terms of the value they have to the livers of those lives.

Use of stem cell lines derived at another institution Sharing stem cells across institutions facilitates scientific progress and minimizes the number of oocytes, embryos, and somatic cells used. Utilitarianism purports to rely upon an amoral criterion in weighing the consequences of human action, but happiness is hardly an amoral criterion.

Instead, the decision to discard the embryos causes their death; research just causes the manner of their death Green A further step was the recent demonstration that human embryonic fibroblasts can be reprogrammed to a pluripotent state using a plasmid with a peptide-linked reprogramming cassette 47However, in comparison to attitudes toward abortion, differences among religious groups are relatively modest.

It would also be acceptable to grandparent lines if gamete donors agreed to unspecified future research or gave dispositional control of frozen embryos to the woman or couple in IVF. A hunter does not shoot if he is not sure whether his target is a deer or a man.

First, there is actual, direct involvement in the wrongful deed, as when a researcher administers the lethal dose to an innocent victim in order to secure tissue samples.

However, some question whether this distinction is viable, especially in the HESC research context. Inevitable Death Versus Utility: This pattern holds for nearly all major religious groups. Furthermore, it may be possible to reidentify the donor of a deidentified large-scale genome sequence using information in forensic DNA databases or at an Internet company offering personal genomic testing 54Furthermore, the treating infertility physicians should not know whether or not their patients agree to donate materials for research.

Ethics of Stem Cell Research

These materials could be deidentified and then used by researchers. Further issues emerge with the prospect of being able to produce large quantities of eggs from stem cells.

Ethical Issues in Stem Cell Research

Jurisdictions that ban payments should accept such carefully considered policies as a reasonable difference of opinion on a complex issue. Could researchers use these materials while appropriately distancing themselves from the wrongful practice. This consent requirement need not imply that embryos are people or that gametes or embryos are research subjects.

This slope has been taken into serious consideration by politicians as it can open a window towards a new set of ethical issues regarding reproductive cloning. The injection of human neural progenitor cells into nonhuman animals has raised ethical concerns about animals developing characteristics considered uniquely human 56 Even though they may not be as diverse, as the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy remarks, from a therapeutic or research point of view, is using these otherwise-discarded embryos for useful research purposes ethical.

And this difference, so the argument runs, cannot justify treating some of these individuals with moral respect while denying it to others. Patients who elect that their embryos be discarded also do not merely foresee the embryos' destruction; their election of that option manifests their intention that the embryos be destroyed.

Nonetheless, the research gives rise to some controversial issues related to embryos, genetics, and assisted reproductive technologies D. Does it have the status of a person. Cell Stem Cell 3: Creation of embryos specifically for research purposes 1. Entry to the computer storage room should also be restricted by means of a card-key, or equivalent system, that records each entry.

While it "recognized the legitimate ethical issues raised by this research," it also asserted that "it would be tragic to waste this opportunity to pursue the work that could potentially alleviate human suffering" http: Many hold a middle ground that the early embryo deserves special respect as a potential human being but that it is acceptable to use it for certain types of research provided there is good scientific justification, careful oversight, and informed consent from the woman or couple for donating the embryo for research 5.

While acknowledging that some people consider embryonic stem cell research to be wrong because of the ethical issues it raises, the AAMC states, "We are persuaded otherwise by what we believe is an equally compelling ethical consideration, namely that it would be tragic to waste the unique potential afforded by embryonic stem cells, destined to be discarded in any case, to alleviate human suffering and enhance the quality of life" http: On the one hand, some object that such payments induce women to undertake excessive risks, particularly poorly educated women who have limited options for employment, as occurred in the Hwang scandal.

the procedures involved in embryonic stem cell research are rooted in moral dispute. Many uphold that this practice is morally impermissible due to the fact that it results in the destruction of human embryos. The central questions regarding the ethics of stem cell research are 2 in number: One, do embryos have any moral status?

In other words, are embryos entities that deserve moral respect and are they owed some duty by moral agents due to their intrinsic properties or relationships with moral agents? Moral Issues Surrounding the Sources of Stem Cells.

At present, there are three possible sources of stem cells: adult stem cells derived from pediatric or adult donors; embryo germ cell stem cells derived from aborted fetuses; and embryonic stem cells () derived from disaggregated preimplantation first of these sources poses no.

Aug 14,  · A clear majority says that embryonic stem cell research either is morally acceptable (32%) or is not a moral issue (36%).

Only about a fifth of the general public (22%) considers embryonic stem cell research morally wrong. Apr 14,  · III. Embryonic Stem Cell Research. Pluripotent stem cell lines can be derived from the inner cell mass of the 5- to 7-d-old blastocyst. However, human embryonic stem cell (hESC) research is ethically and politically controversial because it involves the destruction of human embryos.

Until recently, the only way to get pluripotent stem cells for research was to remove the inner cell mass of an embryo and put it in a dish. The thought of destroying a human embryo can be unsettling, even if it is only five days old.

Moral issues of embryonic stem cell research
Rated 3/5 based on 29 review
Stem Cell Research at the Crossroads of Religion and Politics | Pew Research Center